Headlines
Mitchell: ‘Record High Underfunding’ for Mississippi K-12 Schools
Money, by far, isn’t the only woe for some public schools in Mississippi, but pick a headline anyway:
1. “Legislature Approves Record Cash To Support K-12 Education.”
2. “Legislature Again Ignores Own Mandate, Underfunds Schools By $211 Million.”
Both are accurate.
100 percent.
Last week, the state Senate by a 49-2 vote gave final approval and sent to the governor a bill appropriating nearly $100 million more real dollars for public schools. The total will be $2.2 billion to be added to local taxes, federal dollars and assorted other money to pay for the education of about 490,000 students during the next school year.
It’s an election year. The 90-day lawmaking season is winding down in Jackson. Getting K-12 funding out of the way was smart public relations. It took the topic off the table and out of the vigorous debates that sometimes arise during end-of-session hoopla. Out of sight, out of mind.
Sen. Terry Burton, R-Newton, put it this way in The Clarion-Ledger. “K-12 education is a priority. We’re funding it first. We’re funding it more than it has ever been funded before.”
Unspoken was the fact that the Legislature again disregarded the legal obligation it gave itself to “fully fund” public elementary and secondary schools. Lawmakers haven’t changed the statute that directs the Department of Education to plug enrollment and other figures into formulas to determine the total amount of cash needed to provide “adequate” schools. They just ignored it.
Had the Mississippi Adequate Education Plan been followed, the appropriation would have increased by another $211 million.
Some, including Sen. Hob Bryan, D-Amory, certainly noticed. “I would encourage you to talk to your superintendents, talk to your school board members, talk about what’s going on,” he told his colleagues. “They laid off teachers. They have fewer teachers now than they need. They’re doing things they have to do when there’s not enough money to operate school districts.”
So where is Mississippi doing a good job in education? According to many sources, Mississippi is doing better than most states in equalizing funding among school districts. Those with scarce local resources are getting extra help.
But still not enough as required by law, which is at the core of the citizen initiative that will allow voters in November to bypass the Legislature and of a separate lawsuit filed by several school districts against the state.
Lots has been written about those actions and much will be, so let’s shift gears.
Let’s assume that every school superintendent in Mississippi is given a bottomless checkbook. And let’s ask a question: Would that, of itself, make schools better?
The answer is no.
Witness that the best-funded school district in the nation with the highest-paid teachers (Washington D.C.), is among the worst performing. Witness the range within the 150 or so public school districts in Mississippi. All have about the same money to spend per-student. Some generate top-achievers, have low dropout rates. Others can’t avoid repeated state takeovers for misfeasance and malfeasance.
Once in a while it’s important to talk about this, to state flat-out that $200 million or $200 billion more for public schools would, of itself, fix nothing.
The recipe for effective schools does include sufficient funds, which by its own standards the Legislature is not providing. But there are infinitely more variables, prime among them parental and community support along with appreciation for the value of education, a sense among students and families that a high school diploma is worth earning.
This is what has been lost in failing locales.
The recipe for getting it back is simple to describe, but challenging to put into practice. First, get rid of the assumption that all white-majority districts in affluent areas are peachy and all black-majority districts in poverty areas are abysmal. That’s not accurate.
Next, look at the best practices in the districts that are hitting on all (or most) cylinders and translate or mimic or apply those same practices in struggling districts.
This approach would take energy, initiative and dedication. It would take a relentless commitment to excellence and a zero tolerance for excuses. In sum, it would take a lot more than money. And it would not happen overnight.
If there is any common grounded between those who are adamant that schools are underfunded and those who are proud of the state’s financial commitment, it should be this: Money is an essential ingredient in education. But it is not the only ingredient, not by a long shot.
We all know this. It’s just that when the topic of education funding comes up, we tend to act like money matters most.
Charlie Mitchell is a Mississippi journalist and assistant dean of the Meek School of Journalism and New Media. Write to him at cmitchell43@yahoo.com.
Deborah Elliott
April 8, 2015 at 5:15 am
Again, we are getting ready to list our house. In 2003, we sold our house in Jackson because the schools were terrible. Our son started school in Byram that fall. Our son is now in high school and our daughters are starting elementary. Time to move. The schools in the Byram/Terry feeder pattern have changed so much since 2003. We feel like nomads.
In reference to majority-black schools, most of them–if not all of them—have major disciplinary problems. This creates a ripple effect in many areas. The best teachers don’t want to teach in these kinds of schools. Time to face it—many teachers in majority-black schools spend more time babysitting than actually teaching. Sadly, this is now true in elementary schools as well. Disciplinary problems lead to lower grades and test scores and ultimately higher drop-out rates.
It’s hard to admit it, but black people are like locusts when it comes to Mississippi schools. For whatever reason or a combination of reasons, they just can’t make it work. And, more money won’t be enough to change it. Why is this? I really don’t know. Lack of parental support?!–ok–parents get on the ball and stop making excuses. Lack of community support for the schools? same answer
We want to move from Byram to across the railroad tracks into Florence or Richland. Rankin County School District—I call it the promiseland for public school in central Mississippi. Our house in Florence/ Richland which we will purchase will cost more because of the schools. In contrast, our house in Byram will sell for less money mainly because of the schools. Rankin County School District is 75% white and is one of the best in the state. What do all of the best school districts in the state have in common—they are majority white. When compared to majority-black schools, many of these schools already spend less money per student than majority-black schools.
Education vouchers need to be on the list for next year’s legislative session. Laws were passed for charter schools, but who knows when we will begin to see them. There are many positives when students have the option of being removed from their regular public school setting. Number one–two-three—discipline, discipline, discipline. If a student exhibits poor behavior in a private school or in many charter schools, they can get the hell out. The schools have no obligation to provide those students with other alternatives. In contrast, public schools have to provide all students with an education. Too much money is spent on alternative schools and principals spend too much of their time dealing with behavioral problems. Too much time is spent documenting poor behavior. This true for teachers and administrators.
If vouchers were an option, we wouldn’t be moving. White flight in Byram wouldn’t be taking place at the rate that it is now.
White flight was stepped up at the end of last year. The principals at Gary Rd. Elementary, Byram Middle School and Terry High School were white but, as of this school year, they are all black. The Superintendent of Hinds County Schools was white, but as of this school year, she is black. This doesn’t send a positive message to parents of white students. As it is, the ratios have changed significantly since 2003. The schools were 60% white in 2003. In 2015, they are 76% black.