Allen Boyer: Review of “A Fierce Glory: Antietam” by Justin Martin

“A Fierce Glory: Antietam” by Justin Martin. Photo provided.

The bloodiest day of the American Civil War—a battle bloodier than Pearl Harbor or the attacks of September 11th—was fought in the autumn of 1862, in Maryland farmland rich with corn, on the hills above Antietam Creek.

At Antietam, more than 3,500 Union and Confederate soldiers died, cut down by rifle fire, by grapeshot, by bayonet and butt-stroke. As a white-haired general staggered with a mortal wound, a young Maine lieutenant realized that this was no ordinary battle—“how mighty easy it was to get killed or wounded that day.”

Justin Martin, who wrote the award-winning biography “Rebel

Author Justin Martin.

Souls: Walt Whitman and America’s First Bohemians,” has produced an arresting account of Antietam. He writes with the colloquial tone of a battlefield guide—and, like a battlefield guide, provides expert knowledge of that engagement’s terrain and tactics.

A correspondent for the New-York Tribune called Antietam “the greatest fight since Waterloo.” The musketry was a ceaseless din, remembered as the sound of “rapid pouring of shot upon a tin pan, or the tearing of heavy canvas.” Before rushing the narrow stone arch of the Rohrbach Bridge, the 51st Pennsylvania Regiment demanded that their whiskey ration be restored; it was. The Georgia infantrymen defending the bridge (450 strong, they had held off twelve thousand) had fired off all their ammunition; they had bruised black-and-blue shoulders.

Two generals dominate this history. One is Union commander George B. McClellan, who had fortified Washington and trained the Army of the Potomac—the “Young Napoleon,” clever, ambitious, high-strung, and anxious. He was fond of his troops and reluctant to risk them. Facing McClellan was Robert E. Lee—a stern monolith of a general, older than McClellan, but nimbler and more pugnacious. Unlike McClellan, Lee made ready use of his soldiers. When the fighting at Antietam hung in the balance, Lee’s youngest son, an artillery officer, asked his father if his battered cannon and caissons were going back into the fight; Lee unflinchingly ordered them back.

At Antietam, features of the country landscape have been remembered for the wrack of war that hung upon them: the Cornfield, the Sunken Road, Bloody Angle. Charges and counterattacks slammed into each other, then halted, as the soldiers grew exhausted. Lee’s army fought McClellan’s to a standstill. But looking beyond the battlefield, Martin emphasizes the different way in which Antietam proved a turning point of the war. For beyond Lee and McClellan, a more monumental presence overshadows this book: Abraham Lincoln.

By September 1862, after more than 18 months, the Union government had been unable to suppress the rebellion. A recent run of Confederate victories (at Second Manassas, in the Seven Days fighting on the Peninsula, at Harpers Ferry) had disheartened Republican voters, which threatened Lincoln’s support in Congress. It seemed likely that Britain would intervene, “offering mediation”—which meant, peace talks and Southern independence.

“Over the summer of 1862, during that series of Union setbacks,” Martin writes, “the president began to weigh a new option. “Amid so much pain and sacrifice, something was desperately needed to kindle a fresh Northern commitment to the war effort . . . . Lincoln called a meeting of his cabinet. With all seven members assembled, he revealed his plan to issue an emancipation proclamation.” Secretary of State William Seward, a canny man, suggested that Lincoln issue the proclamation after a Union victory. Lincoln saw the wisdom of this. He wrote out a draft proclamation, put it aside, and waited for a victory.

When Lee’s army fell back across the Potomac, Lincoln decided that Antietam had been a victory. He issued a proclamation that changed a war to save the Union into a war to free the slaves. Sir Winston Churchill, who understood both war and politics, might have called Antietam the end of the beginning of the Civil War.

“A FIERCE GLORY: ANTIETAM —The Desperate Battle That Saved Lincoln and Doomed Slavery,” by Justin Martin. Da Capo Press, 2018. 318 pages. $28.00

Allen Boyer is the Book Editor of A native of Oxford, he lives and writes on Staten Island. His most recent book is “Rocky Boyer’s War” (Naval Institute Press.) A different version of this review was previously published in the Phi Beta Kappa Key Reporter.


This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.